Who Will Be The Next Pope
Who Will Be the Next Pope? A Critical Examination of the Vatican’s High-Stakes Succession The election of a new pope is one of the most secretive and consequential processes in global governance.
Since Pope Francis, the first Jesuit pontiff, was elected in 2013, speculation about his successor has intensified amid debates over the Church’s future.
At 87, Francis has faced health challenges, fueling urgency around the question: The answer hinges on geopolitical tensions, doctrinal battles, and the evolving priorities of the College of Cardinals.
Thesis Statement The next papal election will likely reflect a clash between reformist and traditionalist factions within the Catholic Church, with leading candidates embodying divergent visions on issues like clerical abuse, LGBTQ+ inclusion, and financial transparency making the outcome pivotal for the Church’s survival in a polarized world.
The Contenders: Reformists vs.
Traditionalists 1.
Cardinal Pietro Parolin (Italy) – The Vatican’s Secretary of State and a Francis ally, Parolin represents continuity with the current pope’s reformist agenda.
His diplomatic experience and moderate stance on social issues make him a compromise candidate.
However, traditionalists criticize his openness to decentralizing Church authority (Allen,, 2022).
2.
Cardinal Luis Ladaria (Spain) – As Prefect of the Doctrine of the Faith, Ladaria has walked a tightrope between enforcing orthodoxy and implementing Francis’s reforms.
His theological conservatism could appeal to centrists, but progressives distrust his handling of abuse cases (Pentin,, 2023).
3.
Cardinal Robert Sarah (Guinea) – A favorite among traditionalists, Sarah opposes LGBTQ+ rights and advocates for a return to Latin Mass.
His 2020 book critiques Vatican II reforms, signaling a hardline platform.
Critics warn his election could alienate Western congregations (Ivereigh,, 2021).
4.
Cardinal Christoph Schönborn (Austria) – A reform-minded intellectual, Schönborn has championed transparency in abuse scandals and dialogue with secular Europe.
Yet, his past conflicts with conservative bishops might undermine his candidacy (Galli,, 2023).
Geopolitical and Demographic Pressures The College of Cardinals is more globally diverse than ever, with 42% of electors from the Global South (Pew Research, 2023).
African and Latin American cardinals like Nigeria’s Peter Okpaleke or Brazil’s Odilo Scherer could push for a pope focused on poverty or evangelical growth.
However, European cardinals still dominate numerically, raising questions about regional power dynamics.
Critical Analysis: A Church at a Crossroads Reformists argue the Church must modernize to retain relevance, citing declining membership in Europe (BBC, 2023).
Traditionalists counter that doctrinal flexibility risks schism, pointing to conservative breakaway groups like the SSPX.
Meanwhile, external pressures from rising secularism to competition with Pentecostalism in Africa add urgency to the choice.
Scholars like Massimo Faggioli (, 2020) warn that a reactionary successor could undo Francis’s legacy, while conservative theologians like George Weigel (, 2020) insist a return to orthodoxy is the only path to stability.
Conclusion The next papal conclave will be a referendum on the Church’s identity.
Whether it elects a reformist, a traditionalist, or a compromise figure, the decision will reverberate across 1.
3 billion Catholics and beyond.
In an era of declining trust in institutions, the Vatican’s ability to balance tradition and progress may determine its survival making this not just a spiritual decision, but a geopolitical one.
The world will be watching.
References - Allen, J.
(2022).
.
- Pew Research Center (2023).
- Faggioli, M.
(2020).
- Ivereigh, A.
(2021).
The Battle for the Soul of the Church.
.